← Back to overview

Hearts Redemption

The Quiet of the Pines

The ride north of Rhodes was a sweltering affair, the humid air of the Scarlett Meadows clinging to their skin like a damp wool blanket. Arthur kept his horse, Boadicea, at a steady pace, his eyes constantly darting toward Hosea. The older man was sitting tall in the saddle, but Arthur noticed the way he occasionally adjusted his posture, the slight stiffness in his spine that spoke of a lingering ache.

"You're thinking too loud again, Arthur," Hosea said, his voice carrying easily over the rhythmic clopping of hooves. He didn't turn his head, keeping his eyes fixed on the red-dusted road ahead.

Arthur grunted, shifting his weight. "Just wondering why we’re scouting a trail Dutch probably already knows by heart. Seems like a lot of riding for not much gain."

"It’s not about the trail, and you know it," Hosea replied softly. He slowed his horse, Silver Dollar, until he was riding side-by-side with Arthur. The trees thickened here, the towering pines offering a reprieve from the relentless sun. "Dutch needs to feel like we’re moving. Action is his remedy for doubt. Even if the action is just us riding in circles."

Arthur looked at Hosea, taking in the sharp profile of his face. The light filtering through the canopy dappled Hosea’s grey hair with gold. "And what’s your remedy, Hosea? For the doubt?"

Hosea finally turned to him, a faint, sad smile playing on his lips. "Usually, a good book and a quiet corner. But lately... a bit of peace and quiet with a man who doesn't ask for grand speeches seems to do the trick."

Arthur felt a warmth in his chest that had nothing to do with the Georgia heat. He reached out, his hand hovering near Hosea’s for a fleeting second before he remembered where they were. Even out here, the ghosts of the gang felt like they were watching. He pulled his hand back, settling for a nod.

"There’s a clearing up ahead," Arthur said, his voice dropping an octave. "By the creek. We could rest the horses. Rest ourselves."

Hosea checked the horizon, then the road behind them. "I think the world can spare us half an hour, Arthur."

They turned off the main path, navigating through a dense thicket of ferns and pine needles until the sound of running water reached their ears. The creek was shallow and clear, bubbling over smooth stones. It was a secluded spot, shielded by steep embankments and heavy foliage—a rare pocket of privacy in a life lived in the open.

As soon as they dismounted, the professional veneer they wore like armor began to crack. Arthur moved to Hosea’s side immediately, reaching out to catch the older man’s elbow as he stepped down from the stirrup. Hosea didn't protest the help; he leaned into Arthur’s strength for a moment, his breath hitching slightly.

"Easy now," Arthur murmured.

"I'm fine, Arthur. Just... the dampness in the air gets into the joints," Hosea said, though he didn't pull away.

Arthur led the horses to the water and hitched them loosely to a low-hanging branch. When he turned back, Hosea had sat down on a moss-covered log, his head bowed. The sight sent a pang of protective iron through Arthur’s heart. He walked over and sat down behind Hosea, straddling the log so he could reach the older man’s shoulders.

"Don't start," Hosea warned, though there was no bite in it.

"I ain't sayin' a word," Arthur lied. He placed his large hands on Hosea’s shoulders and began to knead the tight muscles. He could feel the knots, the physical manifestations of every worry Hosea carried for the camp, for Dutch, and for the future.

Hosea let out a long, shuddering sigh, his head dropping forward. "God, you have hands like a blacksmith, Arthur."

"Is that a complaint?"

"Hardly."

They sat in silence for a few minutes, the only sound the bubbling creek and the distant call of a red-tailed hawk. Arthur’s thumbs traced the line of Hosea’s neck, feeling the pulse there—steady, but perhaps a little too fast. He leaned forward, his chest pressing against Hosea’s back, providing a solid wall of warmth.

"You've been coughin' again," Arthur whispered, his lips brushing the shell of Hosea’s ear. "Don't think I haven't heard it just 'cause you try to muffle it with your pillow."

Hosea’s shoulders stiffened for a second before they slumped again. "It’s the dust, Arthur. Or the humidity. My lungs were never meant for the South."

"We should leave," Arthur said. The words felt heavy, dangerous. "Not the gang, maybe. But just... go. For a while. Take some of that money I’ve been squirreling away. Go somewhere dry. Somewhere high up."

Hosea reached back, his hand finding Arthur’s thigh and squeezing it. "And leave Dutch to his own devices? He’d be in a gallows or a grave within a month without me to temper him. And you... you’re his favorite son, Arthur. He’d hunt us to the ends of the earth, not out of malice, but out of a twisted kind of love."

Arthur closed his eyes, burying his face in the crook of Hosea’s neck. The scent of the older man—bay rum, old paper, and a hint of tobacco—was the only thing that made him feel grounded. "I’m tired of being a son, Hosea. I’m tired of being an enforcer. I just want to be... yours. Without the hiding. Without the maps and the schemes."

Hosea turned around in Arthur’s arms, his brown eyes searching Arthur’s face with an intensity that made the younger man feel stripped bare. Hosea reached up, his fingers trembling slightly as he traced the scar on Arthur’s chin.

"You are mine, Arthur Morgan," Hosea said, his voice low and fierce. "In every way that matters. This world... it doesn't deserve to know about us. It would only find a way to use it against us. Our secrecy isn't just for safety. It’s a way to keep this one thing pure. Away from the filth and the blood."

Arthur leaned down, capturing Hosea’s lips in a kiss that was desperate and soft all at once. It tasted of the bittersweet reality they lived in—a stolen moment in a dying world. He pulled Hosea closer, his large arms wrapping around the older man’s thin frame as if he could physically shield him from the passage of time.

Hosea pulled back just an inch, his forehead resting against Arthur’s. "I saw you looking at those brochures for the ranches up in the Grizzlies."

Arthur felt his face heat up. "I was just... dreaming. Like you said."

"It’s a good dream," Hosea whispered. "A small house. A porch where I can sit and watch the sunset without wondering if the Pinkertons are coming over the ridge. You coming home with the smell of cedar on your clothes instead of gunpowder."

"I could make it happen," Arthur insisted. "I’ve got enough tucked away in that copper tin. We wouldn't need much."

Hosea smiled, and this time it reached his eyes, clearing away the shadows of the morning. "Maybe. One day. But for now, Arthur, I need you here. I need you to be the man Dutch thinks you are, so that I can have the man you truly are when the sun goes down."

Arthur let out a breath he felt like he’d been holding since Blackwater. He reached into his satchel and pulled out a small, crumpled paper bag. Inside were two apples he’d swiped from the cook’s wagon. He handed one to Hosea.

"Eat," Arthur commanded gently. "You’ve been skippin' meals again."

Hosea took the apple with a chuckle. "You’re a mother hen, Arthur."

"And you're a stubborn old mule. We’re a fine pair."

They sat on the log, eating their apples in a companionable silence that felt more intimate than any conversation. Arthur watched Hosea, noting the way the tension had drained from his face. For this half-hour, they weren't the lieutenants of a failing dream. They were just two men in love, hiding in the heart of a forest that didn't care about their sins.

As they finished, Arthur stood and offered his hand to Hosea. He pulled him up, but instead of letting go, he drew Hosea into one last, lingering embrace. He tucked Hosea’s head under his chin, feeling the fragile heat of him.

"I mean it," Arthur said into the grey hair. "I won't let 'em take you. Not the law, not the sickness, and not Dutch’s pride."

Hosea squeezed him back, his hands flat against Arthur’s broad back. "I know you won't. You’re my big, brave lion, aren't you?"

Arthur huffed a laugh, the sound vibrating through both of them. "Don't start with the poetry, Hosea. You know I ain't smart enough for it."

"You’re plenty smart, Arthur. You just have a heart that’s too big for your own good."

They walked back to the horses, the heavy air of the meadows waiting for them just beyond the tree line. As they reached the horses, Hosea paused, his hand on the saddle horn. He looked back at the clearing, then at Arthur.

"Thank you, Arthur. For the rest. And for... everything else."

Arthur tipped his hat, his green eyes steady. "Anytime, Hosea. Anytime at all."

They mounted up and began the trek back toward the main road. As they emerged from the shade, the mask returned. Arthur’s face set into its usual stoic mask, his hand moving to the grip of his revolver out of habit. Hosea straightened his coat, his eyes sharpening as he scanned the horizon for potential threats or opportunities.

To any passerby, they were simply two outlaws on a reconnaissance mission. A seasoned veteran and his formidable protégé.

But as they rode, Arthur kept his horse just a few inches closer to Silver Dollar than was strictly necessary. And every so often, when the trail narrowed and their knees brushed together, Hosea would offer a small, private smile that only Arthur could see.

The world was indeed changing, and the noose was undoubtedly tightening. But as the red dust of Rhodes rose up to meet them, Arthur felt a strange, iron-clad peace. He had a mission now that was far more important than any score Dutch could dream up. He was going to get Hosea out. He was going to find that cabin in the pines.

And until then, he would be the storm that broke before it ever reached Hosea Matthews.

As they approached the outskirts of the camp, the sounds of shouting and the smell of stew wafted toward them. Dutch was standing by the campfire, his arms spread wide as he regaled the girls with some story of his youth. Bill was cleaning a rifle, and Micah was spitting tobacco into the dirt.

Hosea took a deep breath, adjusting his hat. "Back to the lion’s den, I suppose."

"I'm right behind you," Arthur said, his voice a low, protective rumble.

Hosea glanced at him one last time before they entered the clearing. "I know you are, Arthur. I always know."

They rode into camp together, the secret they shared burning like a warm coal in the center of their chests, a hidden light in a world that was rapidly growing dark. Arthur dismounted and immediately went to help Hosea with his horse, his movements practiced and casual, hiding the devotion that lived in the touch of his hands.

"Find anything?" Dutch called out, his eyes bright with restless energy.

Hosea smiled, the perfect image of the silver-tongued strategist. "Just a lot of dust and a few quiet spots, Dutch. Nothing we can't handle."

Arthur caught Hosea’s eye and nodded. They would handle it. They would handle all of it, as long as they had the night.