← Back to overview

Hinny

The Cruelest Punchline

The silence of the Astronomy Tower was usually a comfort to Harry, a place where the wind could howl louder than the thoughts in his head. But tonight, the wind was a whisper, and the silence was a suffocating weight. He stood at the edge, his knuckles white as he gripped the stone railing, staring out at the Forbidden Forest. He felt like a ghost, a hollowed-out shell of the boy who had once thought he could defeat death itself.

He reached into his pocket, his fingers brushing the velvet pouch. The ring. The ring that was supposed to be the beginning of forever. Now, it felt like a leaden anchor, dragging him down into the depths of a misery he couldn't escape. Ginny’s words—the real Ginny, not the Polyjuiced impostor—echoed in his mind. *It’s not a marriage; it’s a life raft.*

The sound of footsteps on the stone stairs startled him. He didn't turn. He didn't want anyone to see the raw, jagged edges of his soul. He expected Ron, or perhaps Hermione, coming to offer a platitude or a hug that would only make the hole in his chest feel larger.

"Harry?"

The voice was light, almost airy. It was Ginny.

Harry’s heart gave a treacherous, painful thud. He squeezed his eyes shut for a moment before turning. She was standing by the archway, her hair messy from the wind, her face pale in the moonlight. She wasn't crying anymore. In fact, there was a strange, manic energy in her eyes that he couldn't quite place.

"Ginny," he said, his voice sounding like it had been dragged through gravel. "I thought you went back to the common room. I meant what I said... I'll give you space. I won't—"

"Oh, Harry, honestly," she interrupted, taking a step toward him. A small, sharp laugh escaped her lips. "You really are the most dramatic person I’ve ever met."

Harry froze. The tone was all wrong. It wasn't the heavy, soul-searching gravity of their conversation by the lake. It was something else—something familiar, yet terrifyingly misplaced.

"What do you mean?" Harry asked, his brow furrowing in confusion.

Ginny walked closer, stopping just a few feet away. She looked at him, then at the pocket where the ring was hidden, and then back up at his face. She started to giggle. It wasn't the warm, melodic laugh that usually made Harry feel like the sun was shining; it was a high, thin sound that set his teeth on edge.

"The face you made!" she gasped, clutching her stomach as the giggles turned into full-blown laughter. "Harry, if you could have seen yourself. You looked like I’d personally handed you over to Voldemort. It was perfect."

Harry felt a cold numbness spreading from his fingertips. "The face I made? Ginny, what are you talking about?"

She wiped a tear of mirth from her eye, her breathing shallow. "The proposal. The whole 'I need to be a whole person' speech. The 'life raft' bit? I came up with that one while I was walking down from the owlery. I wasn't sure if you'd buy it, but Merlin, you swallowed it whole!"

The world seemed to tilt on its axis. Harry reached out to grab the railing for support. "You... you’re saying that was a joke?"

"A joke? Harry, it was a masterpiece!" Ginny grinned, her eyes dancing with a light that looked increasingly like cruelty. "After that whole business with Malfoy and the Polyjuice, everyone was so tense. You were acting like I was made of glass, always touching my hand, always looking at me like you were waiting for me to shatter. It was getting exhausting. I thought, what better way to break the tension than to give you a real scare?"

Harry stared at her, his mouth slightly open. He felt like he was drowning in shallow water. "A scare? Ginny, I asked you to marry me. I gave you my mother’s ring. I told you that you were the reason I was still alive."

"And that was the best part!" she chirped, seemingly oblivious to the way the color was draining from his face. "The way your voice cracked? 'Ginny, will you marry me?' I almost lost it right then and there. But I had to see it through. I had to see if I could actually make the Great Harry Potter cry."

She stepped even closer, reaching out to playfully poke his chest. "And I did! You were so miserable. Even Malfoy was impressed. He was hiding behind the pillar, you know. We had a little bet going on whether you’d actually drop to one knee."

The mention of Malfoy felt like a bucket of ice water over Harry’s head. The pieces began to click together in a way that made his stomach churn. The way she had looked at him, the way Draco had appeared so perfectly timed afterward.

"You did this with him?" Harry whispered.

"Oh, don't be like that," Ginny said, waving a hand dismissively. "Draco’s been surprisingly decent lately. We ran into each other after his little stunt, and he was so miserable about failing that I thought, why not turn it into something fun? He helped me refine the speech. He’s got a surprisingly good ear for melodrama."

Harry felt a surge of something hot and violent rising in his throat, but it wasn't anger. It was a pure, unadulterated agony that surpassed anything he had felt in the war. When Sirius died, it was a loss of a father figure. When Dumbledore died, it was a loss of a mentor. But this? This was the systematic destruction of the only thing he had left to believe in.

"It was a joke," Harry repeated, his voice barely audible.

"The best one yet," Ginny said, her smile wide and proud. "Come on, Harry. Give me the ring. I want to see it in the light. We can go down to the common room and tell everyone. Ron is going to lose his mind when he hears how well I pulled it off."

She held out her hand, expecting him to place the velvet pouch into her palm.

Harry looked at her hand. Then he looked at her face. He looked for the girl who had fought by his side at the Department of Mysteries. He looked for the girl who had sent him a singing valentine when she was eleven. He looked for the woman who had held him while he sobbed after the battle.

He didn't see her. All he saw was a stranger wearing the face of the person he loved.

"No," Harry said.

Ginny’s smile faltered just a fraction. "No? Harry, don't be a spoilsport. The joke’s over. You can stop being the tragic hero now."

"It’s not a joke to me," Harry said, and for the first time, his voice didn't shake. It was as cold and dead as the stone beneath his feet. "You saw me break. You saw me at my absolute lowest point, and you thought it was funny."

"Harry, it was just a bit of fun—"

"I was ready to die for you," he interrupted, his eyes locking onto hers with a ferocity that finally seemed to give her pause. "I spent a year in a tent, starving and hunted, and the only thing that kept me from walking into the lake and never coming up was the thought of your face. I came back from the dead, Ginny. I stood in front of Voldemort and I died, and I came back for you."

"I know that!" Ginny snapped, her playful demeanor finally cracking. "And that’s the problem! You’re so heavy, Harry! Everything is life or death with you. Everything is a grand sacrifice. I wanted to see if there was anything left of you that could just take a joke. I wanted to see if you were more than just a martyr."

"And what did you find?" Harry asked, taking a step toward her. He didn't look like a hero. He looked like a man who had finally reached the end of his rope.

Ginny flinched, her back hitting the stone archway. "I found out you’re exactly what I thought. You’re obsessed with your own misery."

Harry let out a short, sharp laugh that had no humor in it. "Maybe I am. But I’d rather be obsessed with my misery than be someone who finds joy in destroying the people who love them."

He reached into his pocket and pulled out the velvet pouch. He didn't look at it. He didn't open it. He simply held it out over the edge of the tower, his hand steady.

"Harry, what are you doing?" Ginny’s voice went high and sharp with genuine alarm. "That’s your mother’s ring!"

"It was a ring for a woman I loved," Harry said. "But that woman doesn't exist. She was just another story I told myself so I could keep going."

"Harry, stop! I was kidding! I do love you, I just—"

"You don't know what love is," Harry said. "Love isn't a game. It isn't a punchline."

He opened his hand.

The small velvet pouch vanished into the darkness, falling silently toward the black waters of the lake far below.

Ginny let out a strangled cry and rushed to the railing, staring down into the abyss. "You idiot! You absolute, blooming idiot! That was a Potter heirloom!"

"It’s just gold, Ginny," Harry said, turning away from her. "Just like you’re just a girl. I thought you were the world, but you’re just... a girl who thinks cruelty is a personality trait."

He walked toward the stairs, his movements fluid and deliberate. He felt remarkably light, as if the weight he had been carrying for years had dropped away with the ring. It wasn't a happy lightness; it was the lightness of a vacuum.

"Harry! Where are you going?" she screamed after him, her voice echoing off the stone walls. "You can't just walk away! We’re Harry and Ginny! Everyone expects us to be together!"

Harry stopped at the top of the stairs and looked back over his shoulder. The moonlight caught the green of his eyes, making them look like cold emeralds.

"Let them expect," Harry said. "I’m done living for what other people expect."

He descended the stairs, the sound of his boots rhythmic and fading.

Ginny stood alone on the tower, the wind whipping her hair into a frenzy. She looked down at the lake, then at the empty space where Harry had stood. The silence of the night rushed back in, but it wasn't a comfort anymore. It was cold. It was hollow.

She had wanted to break the tension. She had wanted to see the "real" Harry.

She had succeeded.

Harry walked through the corridors of Hogwarts, past the sleeping portraits and the flickering torches. He didn't go to the Gryffindor common room. He didn't want to see Ron’s confusion or Hermione’s pity. He walked until he reached the Great Hall, which was empty and vast in the middle of the night.

He sat down at the end of the Gryffindor table, the same place he had sat as an eleven-year-old boy who was just happy to have a place to belong. He looked up at the enchanted ceiling, which was currently a mirror of the night sky—dark, endless, and filled with distant, uncaring stars.

A shadow moved near the entrance.

"I assume the punchline didn't land well?"

Draco Malfoy stepped into the hall, his hands shoved deep into his pockets. He didn't look triumphant. He looked tired, his face drawn and sallow.

Harry didn't look at him. "She told me you helped."

Draco walked closer, stopping a few feet away. He leaned against the table, staring at the empty plates. "I did. I thought it would be funny. I thought... I thought seeing you humiliated would make me feel like I wasn't the only one who lost everything."

"And?" Harry asked.

Draco looked at Harry, really looked at him, and for the first time in seven years, he didn't see a rival. He saw a mirror.

"And it didn't," Draco said softly. "It just made the world feel a lot smaller."

Harry nodded slowly. He didn't feel like fighting. He didn't feel like hexing Draco into the next century. He just felt a strange, weary kinship.

"She threw your ring in the lake?" Draco asked.

"I did," Harry said.

Draco raised an eyebrow. "Your mother’s ring? That’s... bold. Even for you, Potter."

"It didn't belong to her anymore," Harry said. "It belonged to a version of me that died tonight. The lake can have it."

The two boys sat in silence in the cavernous hall, two ghosts of a war that refused to end. Outside, the wind picked up, rattling the stained-glass windows, but inside, the air was still.

Harry thought about the next day. He thought about the whispers in the corridors, the shock on Ron’s face, the tears Ginny would inevitably shed when she realized she couldn't laugh this away. He thought about the life he had planned—the house, the kids, the quiet years of peace.

It was gone. All of it.

But as he sat there, in the quiet dark, he realized something. For the first time in his life, he wasn't the Boy Who Lived. He wasn't the Chosen One. He wasn't Ginny Weasley’s boyfriend.

He was just Harry.

And though the grief was deeper than the lake and colder than the stone, he realized he could breathe. The air was thin and sharp, but it was his.

"Potter?" Draco said, breaking the silence.

"Yeah?"

"I think I’m going to leave," Draco said, standing up. "Hogwarts. I don't think there’s anything left for me here."

Harry looked up at him. "Where will you go?"

Draco shrugged. "Somewhere where nobody knows my name. Somewhere where I don't have to be a Malfoy."

Harry watched him walk toward the doors. "Sounds like a plan," he whispered to the empty hall.

He stayed there until the first grey light of dawn began to creep through the windows. He watched the stars fade, one by one, until only the sun remained. He stood up, stretched his aching limbs, and walked toward the doors.

He didn't look back at the Gryffindor table. He didn't look back at the Astronomy Tower. He walked out of the Great Hall and into the morning, a man with no ring, no girl, and no destiny.

He had never been more terrified. And he had never been more free.